Could McTominay return to Manchester United?
Erik ten Hag says United sold McTominay to Napoli against his wishes in 2024, despite his belief the midfielder should stay.
- EST. FEE
- €30m
- STATUS
- Talks
Why 45%? Three independent outlets report talks, and the numbers are specific. No club statement yet. How we score · Our track record
Update, 20 Oct: Former United manager Erik ten Hag says the club sold McTominay to Napoli in 2024 against his wishes. He says he had argued that the midfielder’s goalscoring and mentality made him important to the team. United received £25.2m, including add-ons, and signed Manuel Ugarte as his replacement that summer. The comments add a new wrinkle to reports that United now want McTominay back.
Update, 7 Oct: United reportedly made an enquiry about bringing McTominay back during the summer, with Aston Villa also enquiring. His agent is said to have held preliminary talks with Premier League clubs, while the midfielder is reportedly open to a return to the UK. He has just over 18 months left on his Napoli deal and is valued at up to £25m.
Manchester United are reportedly considering a move to bring Scott McTominay back from Napoli. The possible return comes as talks over a new contract in Italy are said to have stalled, while a fee of around €30m has been discussed.
Negotiations between McTominay’s representatives and Napoli have reportedly been going on for several months, but an agreement is not thought to be close. The word is that the sides could part ways next summer if the contract situation does not change.
Napoli are said to expect around €30m for the midfielder. By next summer, he would have two years left on his deal, according to the report. That could make the price a point of interest for clubs weighing up a move.
United are linked with an attempt to bring back a player who came through their academy and spent many years at the club. McTominay moved to Napoli and, according to the report, reached a new level there as the Italian side won the league. His return would also reunite him with a club that is reportedly considering adding him to its plans again.
United may not be alone in the chase. Other top teams are also expected to show interest, though no other clubs are named. For now, the key signs to watch are whether Napoli’s contract talks move forward and whether United turn reported interest into an approach. The transfer circus has a familiar face in the ring, but no deal is in place.
Source: Sky Sports (via GiveMeSport), TEAMtalk, CaughtOffside, Sacha Tavolieri (via CaughtOffside)
How the chance moved
- 11 Nov 45% −5
- 4 Nov 50% −4
- 28 Oct 54% −3
- 20 Oct 57% +3
- 15 Oct 54% −3
- 7 Oct 57% +32
- 5 Oct 25% first report
The bigger picture
On our radar since 5 October · 4 independent outlets · peak chance 57%
Who else wants Scott McTominay?
- Real Madrid 5%
Who else are Manchester United chasing?
- Rayan Ait-Nouri 85%
- Calvin Bassey 80%
- Nico Paz 70%
- Malo Gusto 70%
- Alejandro Balde 65%
Follow Scott McTominay
Get an e-mail when a saga about Scott McTominay starts or makes a big move. Nothing else. One-click unsubscribe.
Previously linked
- Now · Oct 2026 Manchester United · peaked at 57% Active
- Oct 2026 Real Madrid · peaked at 5% Went quiet