Could Garnacho make his Aston Villa stay permanent?
Garnacho remains without a Villa start after 95 minutes in seven substitute appearances, while a former scout questions whether he has a future under Emery.
- EST. FEE
- around £43m
- STATUS
- Interest
Why 48%? Three independent outlets report interest, and the numbers are specific. No club statement yet. How we score · Our track record
Update, 10 Nov: Garnacho has now made seven substitute appearances for Villa, totalling 95 minutes, and is still yet to start. Former Premier League scout Mick Brown says his time under Unai Emery may already be over, pointing to his limited involvement and absences from squads. Brown also questions which club would want him if Villa decide against keeping him. Not much of a shop window.
Update, 24 Oct: Villa have reportedly decided, for now, not to give Garnacho enough appearances to trigger the purchase clause automatically. He has played only 31 Premier League minutes this season. Chelsea had reportedly expected the conditions to be relatively easy to meet and anticipated receiving their £43m valuation, so the change in Villa’s approach could leave them facing an uncertain return next summer.
Update, 23 Oct: Villa are reportedly prepared to leave Garnacho out of the team if his form does not improve in the coming weeks, which could let them avoid a permanent transfer. The loan is said to include an appearance-based purchase obligation, reported as a conditional £43m option. Emery recently praised Garnacho’s 20-minute contribution against Viking as his best spell with Villa so far.
Update, 21 Oct: Erik ten Hag says Garnacho needs a coach who gives him trust and support, while keeping him focused and disciplined in defensive transitions. The former manager also revealed that he invited Garnacho to join him at Bayer Leverkusen, but the winger chose to stay in England. Ten Hag praised Garnacho’s attacking ability, while noting that he can sometimes be selfish.
Update, 21 Oct: Fresh reports suggest a permanent Villa move is now in jeopardy, with Chelsea reportedly disappointed by Garnacho’s lack of minutes. He has yet to start for Villa in any competition this season and has played 42 minutes across four substitute appearances. He was also left out of the squad for the win at Newcastle. Unai Emery said Garnacho is behind other players after pre-season circumstances and needs time.
Alejandro Garnacho reportedly wants to turn his season-long loan at Aston Villa into a permanent move from Chelsea. That would keep him at Villa despite a difficult start, with regular football still hard to find.
Garnacho arrived at Villa from Chelsea during the summer after one campaign at Stamford Bridge. So far, he has barely featured under Unai Emery. He has made three Premier League substitute appearances, totalling 31 minutes, but is said to prefer staying at Villa rather than returning to Chelsea.
There is a possible route to a permanent transfer in the loan agreement. Chelsea said the deal includes an obligation to become permanent if certain criteria are met. The reported terms put the move at around €50 million, with enough appearances among the conditions.
Villa are reportedly optimistic that Garnacho’s situation will improve and still expect the conditions to be met, despite his limited playing time so far. People close to the club are also said to be encouraged by his attitude and work in training. For now, though, optimism has to share the stage with the team sheet.
Garnacho is reportedly hoping to establish himself at Villa Park and complete a permanent move next summer. More minutes and a stronger impact would help bring that plan closer; until the appearance conditions are met, the loan remains the main act.
Source: Football365, CaughtOffside, TEAMtalk
How the chance moved
- 10 Nov 48% +10
- 8 Nov 38% −5
- 1 Nov 43% −4
- 24 Oct 47% +8
- 21 Oct 39% +8
- 21 Oct 31% +19
- 14 Oct 12% first report
The bigger picture
On our radar since 14 October · 3 independent outlets · peak chance 48%
Who else wants Alejandro Garnacho?
Nobody else in the last six weeks. Aston Villa have this one to themselves, for now.
Who else are Aston Villa chasing?
- Romeo Lavia 33%
- Endrick 30%
- Santiago Beltran 30%
- Nicolas Raskin 10%
- Kevin Viveros 5%
Follow Alejandro Garnacho
Get an e-mail when a saga about Alejandro Garnacho starts or makes a big move. Nothing else. One-click unsubscribe.